Snapshots of American Cities Then and Now

Some landmarks stand the test of time, while others do not.

From the smallest towns to the biggest cities, change comes to every location sooner or later. What was farmland a century ago might be part of a metropolis now. But, there are some landmarks and touchstones that still remain today. Here are some then and now photos of cities across the US. Some of these locations don’t seem to have changed much while others look (and function) in totally different ways than they used to.

Hippodrome in New York City

Hippodrome Exterior NYC 1903
The original Hippodrome building in 1905. Note the sign that says “The Plunging Horses”. Via: Detroit Publishing Co/Library of Congress

The Hippodrome in New York was once billed as the largest theater in the world, housing circus shows and featuring a novel water tank for aquatic shows. Sadly the building only stood for 34 years. It was built in 1905 and demolished in 1939.

Hippodrome Building Modern Day
The Avenue of the Americas office space AKA The Hippodrome Center in modern times. Via: Beyond My Ken Wiki Commons

Today there is a modern building in its place that was constructed in 1954. The 21-story building is office and retail space today.

View of Brooklyn Bridge and the Financial District

View of Financial District and Brooklyn Bridge from Brooklyn 1913
Section of a panoramic view from 1913. Notice the mansard roofs on some of the buildings. Via: Irving Underhill/Library of Congress

The creation of the Brooklyn Bridge Park removed buildings in the way of the view, such as the mansard roof buildings in the photo above. Across the East River the view of the Financial District is much different, with dozens of skyscrapers looming. In the 1913 photo we can see the newly-constructed Woolworth Building, the tallest building in the world from 1913 until 1930. Just look how the modern skyscrapers dwarf it now!

2020s View of the Brooklyn Bridge
Via: Jakub Hałun/Wiki Commons

The Old North Church in Boston

Old North Church 1920s
The church in the early 1900s. Via: Keystone View Company/NYPL Digital Collections

The steeple of the Old North Church in Boston that we see today is not the original one. Storms tore the first one off in 1804 and it was rebuilt. In 1954 a hurricane took off the refurbished steeple. Over the years the arched windows changed and the clock was removed. When it was completed in 1704 it was the tallest building in Boston (with the height of the weather vane included). Today, this church is still there and many of the older building around it remain as well, retaining the mostly open view unobstructed by skyscrapers.

Old North Church in 2019
Via: Ajay Suresh/Wiki Commons

The Chicago Water Tower

Chicago Water Tower 1930s
Here it is in 1930s. Via: Keystone View Company/Library of Congress

The Chicago Water Tower was built in 1869 to pump water for the growing city. It somehow survived the Great Fire of 1871 and became a historic landmark for Chicago. The castle-like architecture is said to be the inspiration for many of the White Castle restaurants around the the US. Today, many of the larger buildings around it make it look tiny.

Chicago Water Tower in 2018
Via: Roman Boed/Wiki Commons

Pike Place Market in Seattle

1907 Informal Market at Pike Place in Seattle
The open-air market in 1907 was only carts and cars parked along Pike Place. Via: Seattle Public Library

Pike Place Market got its start as an outdoor gathering of vendors in the early 1900s. A series of buildings were constructed over the next decades and by 1920 the area looked much as it does today, minus the skyscrapers in the background.

Pike Place Market in 1919
The market in 1919. Via: Seattle City Archives

A fire in 1974 damaged the Municipal Market Building and it was demolished, although it was rebuilt to look much like it did before.

Revitalization efforts in the 1970s resulted in improvements and changes, though citizen efforts kept the market in line with its early look and layout.

Pike Place Street View
Via: Rootology/Wiki Commons
Subscribe to Dusty Old Thing