Proper DOT dustyoldthing_belowtitle

6 Foods We Just Can’t Believe Were Ever Real

Hot Jezebel

This dish actually sounds yummy once you read the recipe. But, the name takes some getting used to.

Foods We Cannot Believe Were Ever Real

Via/ 12 Tomatoes

Tomato Pie

When American settlers were first introduced to the New World tomato fruit, they naturally thought that the way to serve them was in a sweet dessert pie. Recipes of the era would call for the same kinds of spices used in an apple pie, but strangely it never caught on like apple pie did.

Foods We Cannot Believe Were Ever Real

Via/ Flickr

Rickety Uncle

The name sounds odd and that’s why we have trouble believing that this recipe ever became popular. But, these 4 ingredient oatmeal bars are a familiar (and crumbly) similar to those we ate growing up.

If you enjoyed this then click the “Next Page” button for a look at how dinner has changed over the decades!

Proper DOT dustyoldthing_belowcontent

Get Dusty Old Thing stories in your Inbox!